Five Underrated Fantasy Premier League Picks for Gameweek 5

As the Fantasy Premier League (FPL) nears Gameweek 5, the prevailing template of star players is becoming increasingly clear. Notable names like João Pedro, Erling Haaland, and Arsenal's defense are populating most teams. Yet, with the international break looming, there's a window to capitalize on some less popular picks that can potentially yield high returns.

Utilizing detailed Opta data, here are five players currently owned by fewer than 10% of managers that could make significant contributions this week.

Daniel Muñoz | 5.4m | 5.5% Ownership

The reunion of Oliver Glasner and Daniel Muñoz at Nottingham Forest is generating buzz among FPL managers, especially with struggling Coventry City looming on the horizon. Muñoz, who recently played a full 90 minutes in a win against Aston Villa, was impactful in the game with four touches inside the opposition's box. His creativity also stood out, as he made four chances, second only to Morgan Gibbs-White's seven.

Muñoz is positioned as Glasner’s preferred right wing-back, which bodes well for his minutes moving forward. Given that Coventry has not scored this season and will be missing first-choice striker Taiwo Awoniyi due to suspension, Muñoz's potential for a clean sheet enhances his appeal significantly.

Jayden Bogle | 4.5m | 2.7% Ownership

Currently the top scorer in FPL, Jayden Bogle is surprisingly only owned by 2.7% of managers. While his recent performances have benefited from a degree of luck, with notable returns against Brighton and Newcastle, Bogle has effectively contributed both offensively and defensively by earning clean sheet points.

Despite returning 29 points over the last two weeks, there are murmurs of uncertainty regarding his sustainability. Nevertheless, he remains a strong consideration as Leeds United prepares to host out-of-form Crystal Palace.

Josh King | 5.5m | 1.5% Ownership

Setting sights on a favorable fixture swing, Fulham's Josh King presents a compelling case ahead of their matchup against Manchester United. With the upcoming fixtures against newly promoted teams, capitalizing on King's form could yield significant returns. Despite starting with a challenging opponent, he has found the net twice this season and ranks high among midfielders priced at £5.5m or lower.

Given that only a few budget options have outscored King, his inclusion could save a valuable transfer down the line, allowing for reinvestment elsewhere in the squad.

Marcus Tavernier | 6.1m | 5.2% Ownership

Under the radar yet incredibly effective, Marcus Tavernier has scored in three of four matches for Bournemouth, returning 29 points and situating himself amongst the top midfielders this season. He’s still overshadowed by more popular picks, making him an enticing option for those looking to differentiate their squad while still reaping rewards.

While Bournemouth faces a daunting fixture against Liverpool, Tavernier’s performance metrics indicate solid potential for returns. His expected goals (xG) surpass by a significant margin other options like Alex Scott, making him the preferred choice for managers on a budget.

Thierno Barry | 5.6m | 6.5% Ownership

With Beto's departure to Fiorentina leaving a void in the Everton attack, Thierno Barry emerges as a core figure for the squad. Although he's only netted once this season, his positioning and creating opportunities place him in good stead for scoring against a leaky Ipswich defense, which has conceded heavily thus far. Barry's underlying numbers suggest he could soon see a breakthrough if he converts more of his 'big' chances, making him a worthy gamble at low ownership.

This week marks an opportunity for game-changing selections among these under-the-radar players, potentially altering your squad dynamics as the season progresses. With low ownership percentages, they could provide the much-needed edge in a competitive FPL landscape. Keeping an eye on how they perform during Gameweek 5 could set you ahead of the curve.

*FPL player values and ownership data accurate as of September 16, 2026